New York Red Bulls vs St. Louis City 0-3

St. Louis City won 3-0 at Sports Illustrated Stadium after Rafael Navarro Leal put them ahead in the fifth minute and Simon Becher and Tomas Ostrak added late goals. The visitors controlled the game well enough to turn a one-goal lead into an away win.

Navarro Leal opened the scoring in the fifth minute from Conrad Wallem, and that 1-0 scoreline held through the break. St. Louis City had already taken the lead before New York Red Bulls could settle, and the half-time score was New York Red Bulls 0-1 St. Louis City.

The home side made two changes between the 63rd and 64th minutes, then St. Louis City made two of their own in the 71st minute and another double switch in the 85th minute. Becher, who came on in the 71st minute, made it 2-0 in the 87th minute from Christopher Durkin, and Ostrak, who came on in the 85th minute, sealed it three minutes into stoppage time after replacing Rafael Navarro Leal. New York Red Bulls also made two changes in the 87th minute, but they never found a way back into it.

St. Louis City had 54% of the possession and 502 passes to New York Red Bulls' 423. They also had more shots, 15 to 10, and more on target, 8 to 5, while New York Red Bulls led corners 4-3. The sides were level on fouls at 12 apiece, and New York Red Bulls made 5 saves to St. Louis City's 4.

Timo Baumgartl was booked for St. Louis City in the 35th minute, and Emil Forsberg was booked for New York Red Bulls in the 86th minute.